How to Administer an ICHRA in Gusto, QuickBooks & Rippling: Complete Payroll Integration Guide

By Saif Akhtar, Co-Founder & COO, SimplyHRA. Published and updated November 16, 2026.
Administering an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) does not require locking your company into an expensive, bundled PEO or replacing your preferred payroll provider. By configuring non-taxable payroll reimbursement codes alongside pre-tax Section 125 salary reductions, employers can administer compliant health benefits directly in Gusto, QuickBooks Online Payroll, or Rippling for a flat $29 per employee per month.
Unbundle Your Payroll and Health Benefits
Keep your existing Gusto, QuickBooks, or Rippling payroll setup. SimplyHRA substantiates health insurance receipts and delivers clean payroll reimbursement reports every month.
See How Flat $29 WorksThe Clean Payroll Architecture: Pure-Play HRA vs. Bundled PEOs
Traditional Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) like Justworks or TriNet force employers into co-employment contracts, charging $150 or more per employee monthly just to access group benefits. When a company changes payroll software, its health benefits collapse.
Pure-play HRA administration unbundles these functions: SimplyHRA manages plan documents, compliance, and monthly premium substantiation, while your existing payroll system disburses approved reimbursements. Under IRC Section 105(b), approved reimbursements are completely excluded from gross income on Form W-2 (Boxes 1, 3, and 5).
Platform-by-Platform Setup Instructions
1. Configuring SimplyHRA in Gusto
- Open Settings > Pay Items > Reimbursements in Gusto.
- Click Add Reimbursement and create an item named
ICHRA Health Reimbursement. - Ensure the tax category is set to Non-Taxable. This ensures disbursements bypass federal income tax and FICA calculations.
- If employees choose exchange plans that cost more than their monthly allowance, configure a pre-tax deduction under Benefits > Custom Pre-Tax Deduction (Section 125 Cafeteria Plan) for the employee-paid difference.
- Each month, upload SimplyHRA's verified disbursement report into Gusto prior to running payroll.
2. Configuring SimplyHRA in QuickBooks Online Payroll
- Open Payroll > Employees > Select Employee > Pay Details.
- Under the Additional Pay section, select Add Pay Type and choose Reimbursement.
- Name the pay type
Section 105 HRA Reimbursement. QuickBooks automatically treats reimbursements as non-taxable additions. - Under deductions, add a pre-tax medical deduction under IRC Section 125 if employee payroll deductions are needed for premium balances.
- Enter approved monthly amounts directly from SimplyHRA's substantiation summary before finalizing the payroll register.
3. Configuring SimplyHRA in Rippling
- Open the Payroll app within Rippling and select Settings > Earnings & Deductions.
- Create a custom Earning Code set to Reimbursement (Non-Taxable) labeled
ICHRA Medical Allowance. - Map the earning code to your chart of accounts under Employee Health Benefits expense.
- Import SimplyHRA's monthly CSV ledger report into the payroll run for automated batch population.
Operational Comparison: PEO Bundle vs. Pure-Play Payroll Integration
| Operational Dimension | Bundled PEO (Justworks/TriNet) | SimplyHRA + Gusto/QuickBooks/Rippling |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Administrative Cost | $120 to $180 per employee per month | Flat $29 PEPM (SimplyHRA) + existing payroll |
| Co-Employment Lock-in | Yes (requires changing Federal EIN on payroll) | None (Keep your own corporate entity & EIN) |
| Employee Plan Flexibility | Limited to 1-3 PEO group carrier tiers | Employees choose from all regional exchange plans |
| Receipt & Compliance Substantiation | Carrier direct-billing (opaque invoices) | Automated IRS § 105 substantiation audit |
Need Help Configuring Your Payroll?
Ask Tamara AI: "What pay code do I use for ICHRA reimbursements in Gusto?" or schedule a 15-minute onboarding call with our technical operations team.
Related blogs

Defined Contribution vs Defined Benefit Healthcare: 2027 Small Business Transition Playbook

IRS Accountable Plan Rules: 2027 Employer Guide & Policy Template

